TikTok Turns Its Content Creators Into Brand Advisers Through Deal With IPG Mediabrands

By Stephen Lepitak, published by Adweek

Creator Collective connects clients with the platform’s top talent

TikTok will partner with IPG Mediabrands to offer the agency network more direct access to creative talent on the platform.

The creator and content accelerator initiative will be named The Creator Collective and aims to help guide brands to build “an authentic presence” on the platform that will resonate with TikTok’s community, according to the company’s statement.

The three-year initiative will involve the founding of Creator Camps—sessions with TikTok creators who will meet each quarter with the agency’s clients to offer advice and feedback on their campaign plans.

Also available through the partnership will be training, access to resources and advice on best practices and research and media trial opportunities.

“On TikTok, brands have the unique ability to become creators and storytellers by listening to the community and adopting an always-on approach to their content,” said Blake Chandlee, president of global business solutions for TikTok.

For agency clients, the partnership is aimed at keeping their messaging and tactics relevant.
“As audience reach declines in traditional formats, it is critical that client budgets fund new ways to connect with audiences,” added Dani Benowitz, president of IPG Mediabrands’ investment arm, Magna. “This partnership will deliver incredible value to our clients and, as importantly, will help all of us learn the power of creating content communities at scale.”

The partnership will also see the pair aim to identify new diversity and inclusion initiatives on and off the platform while also looking to benefit nonprofit organizations.

In March it was announced that TikTok had joined the Coalition to End Wildlife Trafficking Online with the platform having guidelines in place that prohibit content that depicts or promotes poaching or illegal trade of wildlife.
 

Read the article in Adweek

ECONOMIC REBOUND WILL PROPEL U.S. ADVERTISING IN 2021, MAGNA FORECASTS

By Ethan Jakob Craft, Published in AdAge
 
Magna’s full-year projection is 2.3 percentage points, or $10 billion in ad revenue, stronger than its previous forecast in December
 
As the U.S. gets back on track following a disastrous 2020, so will the country’s advertising industry. Total ad revenues will rise by billions of dollars, and most marketing channels will stabilize to, or grow above, their pre-pandemic normals, the latest Magna Advertising Forecast predicts.
 
Buoyed by a long-term decline in COVID-19 cases, President Biden’s trillion-dollar stimulus package, and a return to regular sports programming, the advertising industry’s total 2021 revenues are set to increase 6.4% to $240 billion, according to Magna’s new report, released today. That outlook is 2.3 percentage points stronger than the company projected in its previous forecast from December 2020.
 
Excluding one-off spending surrounding events such as last year’s political cycle and the upcoming Summer Olympics in Tokyo, the normalized growth rate for ad revenues this year would be even more significant at 8.6%.
 
“We were always predicting the overall decline of the U.S. market would be moderate,” says the report’s author Vincent Letang, executive VP, global market intelligence at Magna. Not every forecaster was so optimistic at this time last year, he says, but the market eventually proved to be “even more resilient than we thought.”
 
Total ad spend inclusive of cyclical events is simultaneously poised to jump this year by an average of 7.25%; broken down by fiscal quarter, the year-over-year increases may be as high as 15% in Q2 this year against historically sparse spending in 2020, and as low as 2% in Q4, thanks to last year’s major political and holiday spending.
 
This year’s strongest ad spending will come from verticals such as travel, automotive, drinks and entertainment—categories that saw sweeping ad budget cuts last year as consumer demand all but disappeared in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic. Other verticals’ spending growth may not be as robust through 2021, but the silver lining is that few, if any, categories will see a decline this year, Letang says.
 
There is one exception to the rule, though. “One vertical that may not grow very much would be, in my opinion, retail,” he says, citing the industry’s reliance on foundational brick-and-mortar stores, despite an e-commerce boom.
 
In the 12 months since the pandemic became severe in the U.S., everything from groceries to prescription drugs to luxury goods has adapted to a world of online shopping, which may hinder consumers’ swift return to normal. “We’ve had a record number of store closures. It might continue despite the economic recovery,” Letang says.
 
Nearly all ad formats will also see stabilization or growth this year relative to pre-pandemic levels. Social, digital video, search and out-of-home media should all anticipate double-digit growth in 2021, while national TV and radio are in for more sluggish single-digit increases.
 
For the first time, digital formats will account for at least two-thirds of all ad sales, growing 13% to $161 billion this year. The “big three” digital players—Google, Facebook and Amazon—have been outperforming themselves in terms of ad revenues, recording 17% growth in 2020 to now capture 82% of the market share. Social and search ads account for roughly two-thirds of the digital ad market in 2021, Letang adds.
 
He credits the current market’s recovery speed to the prominence of digital advertising, which had less than 20% market share of ad revenues a decade ago, and has seen such major gains that it has supplemented linear advertising’s shaky rebound. Much of that growth can be chalked up to a recent embracing of digital marketing by small mom-and-pop businesses, which Letang calls a “matter of survival” for them.
 
An upswing of rapid growth carried by digital media means the ad market’s recovery time will be just a fraction of what it was during the Great Recession; in fact, total U.S. advertising only posted an actual decrease for one quarter since the outbreak of COVID-19, versus an industry-wide decline across nine consecutive quarters from 2007 to 2009.
 
The industry’s resilience wouldn’t be possible without 2020’s record-setting political ad spend, which topped $8 billion amid a bitter fight for the presidency and partisan control of Congress. And while total revenues were up 75% compared to the 2016 political cycle, a surge in pandemic-related e-commerce and American businesses adopting digital marketing strategies also deserve some of the credit, the report states.
 
Unsurprisingly, another boon this year will be the Olympics, which Magna has assumed are proceeding as scheduled for the purposes of its new forecast. The international sporting event will net between $800 million and $900 million for national TV ad revenues this year, by Letang’s estimation, who notes an unprecedented Olympic double-whammy: Six months after the Closing Ceremony in Tokyo, the 2022 Winter Olympics will be in full swing in Beijing.
 
Read the article in AdAge

MAGNA US Advertising Forecasts – March 2021

Faster than Expected Economic Recovery Will Boost Advertising Spending in 2021

 

KEY TAKEAWAYS

 

  1. MAGNA has increased its forecast for media companies’ advertising revenues in 2021. Advertising revenues will increase by +6.4% to $240 billion. The normalized growth rate would be +8.6% if we neutralize for the impact of cyclical ad spending – generated by elections and Olympics – in both years. That is 2.3 percentage points above the previous MAGNA forecast (published Dec. 2020) due to a stronger economic outlook, supported by the new stimulus package, well-pacing COVID decline, and a return to normal sports events.
  2. Total ad spend (digital and linear, incl. CE) will grow by +6% YoY during 1Q21, by +15% in 2Q21 (against a historically low quarter in 2020), +6% in 3Q21 (with $800m of incremental revenue generated by summer Olympics) and +2% in 4Q21 (comparing with a strong quarter boosted by political spend and record holiday sales).
  3. Improving business conditions will fuel marketing expenditures and allow most industry verticals to grow advertising spending again. The strongest ad spend growth rates will come from Travel, Automotive, Drinks, and Movies, following heavy ad budget cuts in 2020.
  4. Most advertising channels and formats will stabilize or grow ad revenues in 2021, with double-digit growth expected from social media, digital video, search and out-of-home, and low to mid-single-digit growth for national TV and radio. Overall non-political linear ad sales (TV, radio, print, OOH) will grow by +1% to $77 billion (incl. cyclical spending), while digital ad sales (search, social, video, display, audio) will grow by +13% to $161 billion. Digital ad formats will capture two thirds (67%) of total advertising sales for the first time.
  5. Cross-platform editorial media ad sales (linear+digital) will grow by +4% in 2021 (excluding cyclical), with television (including broadcast and cable TV plus long-form AVOD) up +4% and audio (including broadcast radio, streaming and podcasting) up +5%.
  6. The ad market recovered faster than it did during the last recession of 2008-2009. Total advertising (linear+digital) decreased during only one quarter in 2020 (Q2 2020) compared to nine consecutive quarters in 2007-2009. Linear ad spend is suffering just as much as did 11 years ago, but spending is expected to grow again in 2Q21 after four negative quarters compared to 11 consecutive quarters during the great recession.
  7. MAGNA also published its final estimate for the US media owners’ net ad revenues in 2020, that shows even greater resilience than previous estimates: the US market was essentially stable in 2020 at +1% to $226 billion. Non-political growth was also better than expected, at -2%.
  8. The fourth quarter of 2020 was exceptionally strong, based on the analysis of financial reports from media companies, due to economic stabilization, strong holiday sales, and record political spending in October. Year-over-year ad revenue growth reached +12% (still +8% excluding political), but that was entirely driven by – and captured by – digital ad formats (+24%) while linear ad spend were down again (-5%).
  9. The near stability of the ad market in 2020, despite the severity of the economic recession, was greatly helped by all-time high political advertising. Political campaigns contributed seven billion of incremental ad revenues for media owners (+75% vs 2016). Local television attracted the bulk of political spending, as always, but digital political campaign spending grew almost threefold from 2016 to reach $1.5bn.
  10. The resilience of the US ad market in 2020 was also a function of the continued double-digit growth in digital advertising, fueled by a surge in ecommerce and in digital marketing adoption by national brands and local businesses. Digital ad sales grew by +13% overall while social and video formats grew by more than +20%. The “big three” digital giants (Google, Facebook, Amazon) outperformed again, growing ad revenues by +17% to reach a market share of 82%; other digital pure players also grew above average (+27%); by contrast, traditional media companies and independent publishers barely stabilized digital ad sales.

According to Vincent Letang, EVP, Global Market Intelligence, MAGNA, and author of the report: “Our final estimate for US advertising revenues in 2020 confirms that digital marketing was not only resilient but thrived in the COVID, as the organic growth factors all accelerated (shift to ecommerce, digital media consumption, small business adoption etc.) Meanwhile, upper-funnel marketing budget, including branding ad campaigns suffered just as much as in the previous recession. The latest economic and business outlook for 2021 gives us confidence that most industry verticals will grow ad spend again, up and down the funnel, and that will benefit nearly all media channels this year”.

 

Next MAGNA forecast update (US and global): June 2021

 

US AD MARKET GROWTH (ALL MEDIA NET AD REVENUES 4Q20-4Q21)

 

YOY growth 4Q20 1Q21 2Q21 3Q21 4Q21
Excl. Cyclical +8.1% +7.4% +15.7% +6.9% +5.9%
Incl. Cyclical +12.3% +6.2% +14.9% +5.8% +1.6%

 

Source: MAGNA March 2021. Cyclical ad spend includes political (2020) and Olympics (2021)

 

KEY MAGNA FORECASTS

 

  4Q20 FY 2020 FY 2021 Market
Shares
Growth (%) Growth (%) Growth (%) Previous
Total Market (All Media, incl. CE) 12.3% 0.6% 6.4% 4.1%
Total Market (All Media, excl. CE) 8.1% -1.6% 8.6% 6.0%
 
Linear Ad Sales (incl. CE) -5.4% -16.1% -2.9% -2.6%
Linear Ad Sales (excl. CE) -14.6% -20.2% 1.2% 0.9% 32.5%
National TV (excl. CE) -5.4% -11.6% 3.4% 3.3% 16.1%
Local TV (excl. CE) -7.1% -18.7% -2.5% -3.7% 6.0%
Print -27.4% -31.6% -14.4% -13.0% 3.2%
Radio -27.4% -31.0% 2.1% 1.4% 4.0%
OOH (excl. Cinema) -23.9% -24.6% 11.5% 11.3% 2.9%
Cinema -89.6% -79.9% 151.8% 123.1% 0.1%
Digital Ad Sales (incl. CE) 24.4% 13.2% 11.7% 8.0% 67.7%
Search 22.6% 11.6% 12.4% 8.4% 32.9%
Video 35.3% 23.1% 14.1% 11.7% 8.4%
Social 32.5% 21.4% 14.1% 9.6% 20.7%
Digital Audio 19.9% 5.6% 7.5% 7.0% 1.5%

 

Source: MAGNA March 2021. CE=Cyclical Ad Spend.

 

ABOUT MAGNA

MAGNA is the leading global media investment and intelligence company. Our trusted insights, proprietary trials offerings, industry-leading negotiation and unparalleled consultative solutions deliver an actionable marketplace advantage for our clients and subscribers.

We are a team of experts driven by results, integrity and inquisitiveness. We operate across five key competencies, supporting clients and cross-functional teams through partnership, education, accountability, connectivity and enablement. For more information, please visit our website: https://magnaglobal.com/ and follow us on LinkedIn and Twitter.

Full reports and databases are available to Mediabrands clients and MAGNA subscribers. To learn about our subscription-based market research program, contact [email protected].

 

Press Contact: Zinnia Gill ([email protected])

Author: Vincent Letang, EVP, Managing Partner, Global Market Intelligence

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

NEW STUDY: RESEARCH FINDS MOST COMMON ADVERTISING TACTICS ARE ALIENATING PEOPLE, LEADING TO APATHY

NEW DATA FROM MEDIAHUB & MAGNA PROVES THE NEED FOR CHANGE & THAT IN DIGITAL, LESS IS MORE

New York, NY – March 23, 2021 – “The In’s and Out’s of Ad Sentiment” – a new study released today by Mediahub and MAGNA– finds that a number of the most common advertising tactics are actually contributing to people’s increasingly negative perceptions of online advertising. The research reveals that people aren’t inherently opposed to online advertising, they just don’t love or trust the ads they are served. While the result is consumer apathy, the research offers solutions for how the industry can address the issue.

This study, conceived and undertaken by Mediahub in partnership with MAGNA, was conducted in the US and Australia in late 2020 and uncovered the factors that determine how people feel about online ads, which included ad load, targeting strategies – or lack thereof – and the content within the ads themselves. While the strongest driver of negative sentiment in the US was heavy ad load, many of the other drivers reveal the need to find an appropriate balance with tactics. For example, the ad industry has historically sought to engage customers with more and longer ads with “attention-grabbing design elements” like music, but the study found that in the case of online advertising, less is actually more.
 
Additional key findings of the study include:

  • Strike the right targeting balance: Ad targeting showed the most room for improvement. Many people are getting too many ads that are aggressively pushing them to buy and frustrated that these ads continue after they have already bought. Brands can remedy this with exclusion pixels. While lack of targeting leads to irrelevant ads, improper use leads to creepiness and annoyance.
  • Music is polarizing: Music can be a positive addition, but taste is subjective. In addition, many report feeling overwhelmed by the volume of music within ads.
  • Current events can be a double-edged sword: Ads addressing current events were a significant driver of overall ad sentiment, but people have mixed opinions. Many cited brands’ approach to COVID-19 and the feeling that too many brands jumped in, quickly leading to annoyance.

 
Encouragingly, MAGNA and Mediahub found that most factors contributing to the decline in ad sentiment are within advertisers’ control to address, with strong incentives to do so:

  • 71% of those surveyed said they have or considered disabling or not using ad blocking software as a result of having a positive opinion of online advertising.
  • What benefits people, benefits brands. Ad effectiveness testing revealed when many of these tactics are done well, brands get a bigger lift in KPIs.
  • Reducing the number of ads seen daily and improving ad targeting alone would improve overall ad sentiment by 34%.“As consumers spend more time with digital media, it’s crucial for the industry to understand what’s driving negative feelings toward online advertising so that we can do our part to improve it,” said Kara Manatt, SVP, Intelligence Solutions, MAGNA. “Bombarding people with ads is not working. It’s annoying and only encourages more ad avoidance. We need to focus on fewer, better ads that are thoughtfully targeted.”

 
What advertisers should do next:

  • Brands should focus more carefully on the consumers who are truly in the purchase consideration stage, giving them meaningful reasons to buy, rather than just frequent reminders.
  • Music should be used thoughtfully to ensure it aligns with audience interests, particularly for global advertisers.
  • When touching on current events within advertising, advertisers should be mindful of authenticity and timing.
  • Plan fewer, better ads. Ads in an uncluttered environment are worth a premium.

In conducting the research, a nationally representative audience of 1,354 Americans were interviewed online. In addition, controlled ad effectiveness testing was conducted to test 44 different ad types across 4,278 participants on YouTube.

DOWNLOAD THE FULL REPORT

About MAGNA

MAGNA is the leading global media investment and intelligence company. Our trusted insights, proprietary trials offerings, industry-leading negotiation and unparalleled consultative solutions deliver an actionable marketplace advantage for our clients and subscribers.

We are a team of experts driven by results, integrity and inquisitiveness. We operate across five key competencies, supporting clients and cross-functional teams through partnership, education, accountability, connectivity and enablement. For more information, please visit our website: https://magnaglobal.com/ and follow us on LinkedIn and Twitter.

About IPG Media Lab

Part of the Interpublic network, the IPG Media Lab identifies and researches innovations and trends that will change the media landscape and how brands engage with their audiences. Since 2006, the Lab has worked with our clients and with industry partners who can help them best adapt to disruptive change. Its expertise, resources and consulting services also help to inform the learnings, strategies and business outcomes of all Interpublic agencies. For more information, please visit www.ipglab.com or follow @ipglab.

Media Contact:

Zinnia Gill

Mediabrands

Director, Global Corporate Communications

(646) 965-4271

[email protected]

ONLINE ADS ARE TURNING OFF CONSUMERS—HERE’S WHY

By Ethan Jakob Craft, Published in AdAge
 
New report from Magna and IPG’s Mediahub finds less is more when it comes to marketers’ digital messages
 
Some of the most common tactics used in online ads might actually alienate consumers and contribute to the public’s increasingly negative perceptions of advertising, a new study from Magna and IPG’s Mediahub has found.
 
Dubbed “The Ins and Outs of Ad Sentiment,” the report released today examined peoples’ feelings towards various aspects of online advertising including frequency, message content, targeting strategies and more, and found many simply feel “meh” towards online ads. While few actively trust and engage with online advertising, not many more oppose it, with the majority of those surveyed reporting indifferent feelings.
 
The study was conducted late last year among consumers in both the U.S. and Australia.
 
“We saw with this research that there is generally a negative, or sort of apathetic opinion towards online advertising,” says Kara Manatt, senior VP of intelligence solutions at Magna.
 
One of the biggest turn-offs for consumers of online advertising: heavy ad loads. With messages popping up back-to-back all day long, people report feeling harassed or annoyed—especially when they continue to be served ads for products they’ve already purchased.
 
Reducing the number of ads shown to consumers on a daily basis, coupled with improved targeting formulas, could boost overall ad sentiment by more than one-third, the Magna and Mediahub study found.
 
However, ad targeting is a double-edged sword, the study shows. Serving consumers non-targeted online ads often equals showing them irrelevant content, which tends to heighten apathy and disengagement; on the flip side, hyper-personalization or improper use of targeting can drive feelings of creepiness, making people weary of the offending advertiser. In addition, targeted ads that are aggressively product-focused tend to turn away consumers.
 
“Our industry’s tendency to deliver more and more ads is really backfiring,” Manatt says, though the issue is not so cut-and-dried. U.S. consumers who participated in the new study were twice as likely to cite overwhelming ad load as a driver of negative sentiments than their Australian counterparts, she says.
 
As of late 2020, when the study was conducted, just 12% of consumers reported believing that “online ads are good for society” and only 10% said they completely trust online ads; conversely, 17% said they’re bad for society and 28% responded that they don’t trust online ads at all.
 
It’s the in-between of those numbers where the silver lining lies: The vast majority of people surveyed reported neutral feelings, meaning there’s lots of room for online marketers to make inroads with the public, Manatt says. “That’s really our opportunity to hopefully improve things, build consumer advertiser trust, and hopefully get people feeling more positive about advertising.”
 
In general, less is more when it comes to online advertising—creating more impactful, less frequent ads in a non-cluttered environment is what the bulk of consumers respond well to, she adds. Sponsored content also should be clearly marked as such to maintain strong consumer trust.
 
“The industry, and actually individual companies, should have a vested interest in lowering the ad clutter,” she adds. “It’s also something that we know will make their individual campaigns work harder.”
 
What is clear from the study is that there’s little consensus among consumers about what makes online advertising effective versus what makes it annoying.
 
Including music in online ads, for example, can be an engaging add-on for some consumers, although it’s a very subjective creative element that can just as easily be perceived as annoying—particularly when the tracks feature “pounding beats or screeching guitars,” the study says. On the whole, including music in an online ad is a negative factor.
 
Creating ads centered on current events was another point of contention among respondents. Brands engaging with such issues is a tactic generally looked upon favorably, according to the study.
 
But while acknowledging current events can help increase the entertainment value of an ad, doing so inauthentically can hurt an advertiser’s reach—as was the case when everyone and their mother jumped on the “we’re here for you” bandwagon during the first wave of COVID-19 last year, leading many consumers to tune out such messages.
 
“If it’s not authentic, it’s not going to work and it’s going to backfire,” Manatt says. “What we’re seeing six, eight months later,” after the initial rush of solidarity ads, she says, “is there’s a lot of brands that kind of jumped on that bandwagon and felt that they had to have a message related to COVID no matter what.”
 
And while consumers might not hold a grudge against any particular brand for serving that type of message, being bombarded by similar ads all at once is a turn-off. “Timing is almost as important as authenticity,” she adds.
 
Read the article in AdAge
Read the Press Release
Download the Full Report